Understanding the Classification
The 1855 Classification remains the cornerstone of Bordeaux's reputation, a hierarchy created at the request of Emperor Napoleon III for the Paris Exposition. The merchants of the Bordeaux trade ranked the chateaux of the Medoc and Sauternes into five tiers, from Premier Cru (First Growth) through Cinquieme Cru (Fifth Growth), based on decades of trading prices and reputation.
The five First Growths of the Left Bank are Chateau Lafite Rothschild, Chateau Latour, Chateau Margaux, Chateau Haut-Brion, and Chateau Mouton Rothschild. Remarkably, only one reclassification has ever occurred: Mouton Rothschild was promoted from Second to First Growth in 1973, following decades of campaigning by Baron Philippe de Rothschild.
The Right Bank operates under a separate system. Saint-Emilion has its own Grand Cru Classe classification, which is reviewed approximately every decade, creating a more dynamic but sometimes controversial ranking. Pomerol, home to the legendary Petrus, has never had an official classification at all.
Where the True Value Lies
While First Growths command the highest prices, the most astute collectors look to what are known as the Super Seconds for quality that rivals the top tier at a fraction of the price. Estates such as Leoville-Las Cases, Pichon Baron and Cos d'Estournel consistently produce wines of First Growth calibre, often scoring within a point or two of their more illustrious neighbours.
The Right Bank has also seen a surge of interest, with estates like Canon and Figeac earning their place among Bordeaux's elite. The 2022 reclassification of Saint-Emilion elevated Figeac to Premier Grand Cru Classe A status, reflecting what the market had long recognised.
The essential lesson for collectors is that classification does not always reflect current quality. A well-run Fifth Growth can produce wine that outshines a complacent Second Growth. The key is to follow the estates, not just the rankings.
Navigating Vintages
Vintage variation affects Bordeaux more than most wine regions. The maritime climate brings unpredictability, and even with modern viticulture, the differences between years remain significant. Understanding vintages is essential to making intelligent purchases.
The 2018 and 2019 vintages are widely regarded as modern greats, producing wines of exceptional concentration and balance. The 2020 vintage, harvested during the early months of the pandemic, proved exceptional despite the challenges, with many estates reporting some of their finest wines. The 2022 vintage is emerging as highly promising, with early assessments suggesting another excellent year.
When reading critic scores, look beyond the headline number. A 95-point wine from a challenging vintage may offer more intellectual interest and earlier drinking pleasure than a 98-point wine from a blockbuster year. The scores tell part of the story, but the context tells the rest.
"The greatest Bordeaux wines are not merely beverages. They are liquid history, the distilled essence of a place and a moment in time."

